Comments on: Should You Sell Your Car or Trade it In? – The Math Might Surprise You! https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/ Personal Finance for Military, Veterans, and their Families Wed, 25 Feb 2026 02:41:17 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0 By: Ryan Guina https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-188408 Wed, 02 Apr 2025 19:03:43 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-188408 In reply to Steve Smith.

Hello Steve, Most states do not require you to pay taxes when you sell a personal vehicle, so long as you are not flipping vehicles as a business. You can contact your state for more specific information or with further questions. Best wishes!

]]>
By: Steve Smith https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-187440 Tue, 25 Mar 2025 00:06:44 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-187440 I bought a new truck recently. I asked about trading in my existing truck. “Yes,” they said, “We’ll give you $525 for it.” It was a definite “NO!” from me. I sold it the next day for several thousand dollars. And I used this money as part of the $15,000 down payment on the new truck. Do I pay tax on the sale of the old truck, since it was used in the new purchase?
thanks,
Steve Smith
Tennessee

]]>
By: Milford Bill https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177484 Fri, 01 Jan 2021 20:10:34 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177484 Thanks for the excellent example and “formula” for the computation. You made it very easy for me to release the idea of selling my car for a slightly increased price, which sounds good until the tax considerations are entered. Trade-ins definitely make the whole process simple and quick.
Nicely done for a non-financial car shopper/buyer.

]]>
By: Tomasz https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177483 Tue, 20 Aug 2019 20:19:32 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177483 Thank you for providing the examples and reminding everyone about having to pay taxes only on the difference between the MSRP – Trade In. However, as you noted it doesn’t always make sense to trade your car in for a new one. Especially, if you car’s been already paid off, you take pride in ownership (keeping up with the vehicle maintenance, regularly cleaning the car) or if you have a vehicle, which is rare, antique or one with only enthusiast following.

Having said that, there are examples of people losing thousands of dollars by taking the “easy road” and trading in their well taken care of, paid off vehicle. A little effort can produce a difference of $2,000+ by selling the car yourself. I have proven this concept time and time again but I’m different than most people out there in a sense that I don’t mind the work of cleaning the vehicle, keeping the service records, marketing it and going through the payment transaction.

]]>
By: Ryan Guina https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177482 Tue, 01 May 2018 15:02:05 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177482 In reply to Tim.

Hello Tim, I’m not sure I understand the situation.

It sounds like you want to buy a car that the dealer is selling for $20,000. You owe $14,000 on your trade-in, for which the dealer is offering $10,000. You are willing to pay cash for the $4,000 you are upside down on your trade.

If that is the situation, then it would seem that you would only owe $10,000 for the new car.

This is also what you write in your comment, : Now then for the sake of discussion on their 20,000 new car the trade difference would be my car plus 10,000 to close the deal. Plus I need 4,000 I am upside down to make up the difference.”

So if you are paying the $4,000 difference on your loan, it essentially boils down to their car at $20,000; Your car reduces this by $10,000, and you pay $4,000 cash to settle the outstanding balance on your current car loan.

Any other math is probably there to confuse you and wrap additional fees into the car loan. I wouldn’t work with a car dealer that is trying to make things more complicated than necessary. I would walk away and find another dealership to work with.

]]>
By: Tim https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177481 Tue, 01 May 2018 02:11:35 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177481 Question? I have a 2012 Toyota Camry dealers are telling me it’s worth 10,000. I owe a little over 14,000 on the car so I’m upside down. Now then for the sake of discussion on their 20,000 new car the trade difference would be my car plus 10,000 to close the deal. Plus I need 4,000 I am upside down to make up the difference. The question here is this if I am coming up with the 4,000 difference that I am upside down why are they rolling the 14,000 payoff back into the price of their 20,000 car? Essentially I am giving them my car for free that they say is worth 10,000, plus they are rolling that 10,000 back into the financing of their car. Their math looks like this.

20,000 new car
10,000 trade allowance
10,000 trade difference
4,000 neg equity
6,000 new balance
14,000 plus payoff
20,000 out the door

Should it not be 16,000 financed out the door instead of 20,000?

]]>
By: Jasmine https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177480 Fri, 05 Jan 2018 23:47:09 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177480 Do you know if Ohio is under this law as well? ” In most states, when you trade-in your car when purchasing another vehicle, you are only required to pay sales tax on the difference between the trade-in value and the price of the new car.”

]]>
By: Ryan Guina https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177479 Mon, 13 Oct 2014 16:31:20 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177479 In reply to Brooke.

Brooke, you should receive a check from the dealership for the difference in value. Keep in mind the dealer will likely quote additional expenses on the cost of the $14,000 vehicle, including things like documentation, dealership fees, registration, etc. But the sales tax may be canceled out. You can also try to negotiate the price of the $14,000 vehicle, and maybe get it for less. Try calling the dealership and asking them exactly how the process would work and what you might expect. If you are concerned about asking the dealership where you will be making the deal, then you can try asking a car salesman (if you know one personally) or you can call another dealership and mention you are considering trading in a high value vehicle for a lower cost vehicle and you want to know how the process works. Hopefully they will be able to tell you what to expect. I hope this helps!

]]>
By: Brooke https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177478 Sat, 11 Oct 2014 12:04:11 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177478 How would this work out if the trade in value was higher than the price of the vehicle you are purchasing? We are considering trading in our current vehicle, which dealers have offered us $17,500 for, on a vehicle that costs about $14,000. Thanks for the article and any info you have to offer!

]]>
By: james https://themilitarywallet.com/sell-your-car-privately-or-trade-in/#comment-177477 Wed, 11 Dec 2013 16:22:38 +0000 http://cashmoneylife.wpengine.com/?p=2371#comment-177477 I tried and tried to get the value of my car. I always get other stuff. I have a 2000 Buick custom sedan. low miles, real low. everything OK however: results show 150,000 miles. tried something other, could not get what I needed?

]]>