Comments on: A Military Retirement is Worth Millions of Dollars https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/ Personal Finance for Military, Veterans, and their Families Wed, 25 Feb 2026 01:44:12 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0 By: andy walters https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-184469 Mon, 02 Sep 2024 12:55:13 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-184469 I spent four years in the Navy from 1986 to 1990. It was a great experience, allowing me to see different parts of the world. When my service ended, I left immediately. Afterward, I took every civil service test I could find—Fire Department, Corrections, NYC Bus Operator, etc. The Bus Operator position called first, so I worked there for two years. Then, I was appointed to Corrections, but I didn’t like it and went back to transit. About a year later, the New York City Fire Department appointed me.

That’s when I discovered why they call it “the greatest job in the world”—because it truly is. However, I was injured while working at Ground Zero during 9/11. I had only 12 years on the job at the time, but I was awarded a tax-free ¾ pension of $109,750 per year. FDNY pensions are among the best, not to mention full medical benefits.

When I left the Navy, the chiefs told me not to, saying I’d end up flipping burgers at McDonald’s. They lie to you to keep you in, but I think McDonald’s probably pays better than the military these days, haha. Seriously, if I had stayed in and retired, I would be getting around $12,000 a year. I now make close to that in just one month.

One of my retired Navy friends, who left as an E-8, only gets $2,600 a month in retirement. He’ll have to work for the rest of his life. People don’t think about this, and military retirees are often taking jobs that young people need because, in some cases, their pensions can’t even cover a mortgage. I see it all the time, so I encourage young people to go to big cities and take civil service tests.

Not to mention, the BS you have to put up with in the military ages you quickly. My retired Navy neighbor here in Florida is younger than me, but he looks 20 years older. He and his wife had to sell their house and move to North Carolina just to afford a living.

Bottom line: military retirement isn’t as good as it’s made out to be. It’s like being on a hamster wheel—you end up working for the rest of your life. I’m just speaking the truth here.

Good luck to all, and stay safe. Cheers.
Andy

]]>
By: Andy https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-180534 Fri, 28 Apr 2023 21:42:18 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-180534 I was raised in Cuba under the oppression of the Castro regime before my parents brought my brothers and I to the US in 1995. I realized early on that this was the most positive life change a child could have – to move to the US from a communist state.

I joined the Army two weeks after graduating high school. I humbly served over 21 years as enlisted and as a Warrant Officer, retiring as a CW2 in July 2022. I now receive retirement and disability benefits, and if I make it another 40 years, my retirement will be worth over $3.4 million. And that is not including the healthcare benefits and all the other things. And, if my wife survives me, she will receive 50% of my retirement and my disability benefits. There are other benefits for military retirees/disabled veterans that vary by state, so I won’t discuss them here.

Now, I compare this with my fellow elementary students in Cuba that either served or are still serving in the Cuban armed forces, who don’t even have food to eat. One single egg costs about $3, one pound of pork meat costs about $20, and the average monthly salary of a Cuban worker is about $100, just to state a few facts. And guess what, potable water is only available for short periods at a time. Electricity is only available for a couple of hours a day, and they get lucky if it’s during the day and they are able to escape the heat in front of a fan.

My point with stating all of this is that America is great. Every US resident should aspire to serve their nation.

]]>
By: Mark https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-179625 Tue, 13 Dec 2022 08:39:31 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-179625 It’s so worth it to stick with it. Medical alone saves us thousands of dollars per year. I retired after 23 years as an E-8, and my monthly income was $2,292 in 2006. Now it’s $3,437 monthly at age 59. This has allowed us to send our youngest to private school while living in Hawaii. Granted, I must continue to work to live in paradise! So worth it!!!

]]>
By: robert davis https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-176172 Mon, 11 Jul 2022 08:35:52 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-176172 I retired in 1995 after 20 years in the US Navy. To be honest, there were a lot of things I didn’t like about navy life, being away from my family for Westpac’s, constantly being at sea, and having to move every few years, among many other things. But I’m coming up on 66 years old now. And without hesitation, I have to say that staying in till retirement was without a doubt the smartest thing I ever did in my life. The retirement pay and medical benefits can’t be beaten in the civilian sector.

]]>
By: Dave Twombly https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-164240 Tue, 22 Dec 2020 17:36:23 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-164240 From the time I used a government pen to sign up at the age of 16 then the transportation, uniforms and equipment .Weapons and ammunition. housing ,food, medical care. serve 21and ahalf years as E7 with 60 0/0 disability . The space A travel and with 51 years since retirement I believe I have received more then a million dollars.

]]>
By: Simple Sailor https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-161050 Sat, 27 Jun 2020 22:25:43 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-161050 In reply to Difu Wu.

As several have commented here, the meaning of value can have a different meaning. I took a slightly different perspective looking at my monthly military retirement income stream and VA disability compensation which started at 42 upon retiring from active duty. I’ve read that financial planners often use the 4% guideline for drawing down on a lump sum to perpetuity i.e. .04 x $1M will give you $40K annually to spend…in general. At least in those terms today’s E7 and definitely 05s are in that situation even with the new avg of the high 3’s plan now in place. Plus military retirement Tricare is still small compared to private sector, less than $100/month for me and the spouse. Plus for those drawing VA disability, that portion is tax free. Someone mentioned it definitely was sweat equity so we were not deducted from any of our paychecks while we were on active duty. Of course the drawback to that is 8 moves over a 20 year career which made my wife’s career impractica; no great equity in a house at age 42 moving all over and with mandated govt quarters overseas; the emotional costs of being away from family, missing big events due to patrols/deployments; of course the arduous and dangerous nature of the work itself; and starting over trying to wedge your into private sector work 20 years behind your competitors/peers. So you do earn that military pension in other ways. But now retired with most of my health intact, the pension and health care coverage are definitely beneficial and in my opinion worth at least $1M in that perspective!

]]>
By: cc https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-160646 Thu, 26 Mar 2020 19:39:34 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-160646 In reply to CC.

Difu, you are equating value to how much a pension can be sold for. Generally, it is almost never advantageous to sell a pension because it is sold at a discounted rate. Anyone considering doing so should definitely speak with a financial planner (Many VAs provide one) before doing so. It is the same thing as the tv advertisements that offer to buy legal settlements that are paid out over time…a million dollar settlement paid out over 20 years can be sold for immediate cash at a steep discount.

A second way to value a military retirement is replacement cost…how much would it cost in the public market to get a guaranteed payment for life. For example if we look at how much would it take to purchase an annuity for a 42 year old for say $4k payments a month for the life of person and their spouse to start paying immediately, the cost of the annuity would be well over $1m dollars. And the annuity would not include cost of living increases like a military retirement does. There are lots of annuity calculators you can use on the internet if anyone wants to look.

As I said before, a military pension is different than most current retirement plans out there. It is guaranteed…yes the US government could fall as you point out, but if that were to happen any other investment would also be pretty much worthless…and again an unlikely event in our lifetimes. It is not the same as stocks which can have wild fluctuations in value in the short term….which matters for people that are using the money for their monthly expenses.

]]>
By: Difu Wu https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-159960 Fri, 13 Dec 2019 20:26:51 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-159960 In reply to CC.

@CC: I factored in COLA already in the 7% discount rate I used, which is the REAL stock market return, not nominal. The growing perpetuity formula is PMT/(R-G), where G is the growth rate. If you use 10% nominal return rate and 3% inflation rate, you get the same 7%.

It is important to note that 7% discount rate is not just my opinion. It is the rate used by the BRS lump option option. If you choose the lump sum option, 7% discount rate is what you get.

People who retire from the military generally have decades more residual life expectancy, which is a long term investment horizon. Fixed income options that earn only 2% a year guaranteed are only appropriate for short term savers, certainly not for long term investors.

Over any 30 year period since 1926, the stock market has returned an annualized 8% to 15%. While that is no guarantee the same will hold for the future, it’s pretty close to one, considering that this data included the Great Depression. Arguably, military pensions are not guaranteed either. The government could default or be overthrown.

My assumptions are actually very generous for the military pension. First, nobody lives forever. If you calculate the value of the pension as an annuity instead of a perpetuity, the value would be less.

Second, 12% bracket assumes the retiree has no other income. That is not true for many folks I know. Many retire from the military after 20 years only to work on a GS or civilian job. Using a higher tax rate, such as 24%, would make the pension worth much less. A more realistic value for the military pension is likely to be worth only half a million for the retired O-5, and far less for the retired enlisted man.

]]>
By: Dave https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-159846 Fri, 22 Nov 2019 12:41:48 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-159846 In reply to CC.

CC: this is the best summary. Thanks!

]]>
By: CC https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-worth-millions/#comment-159734 Wed, 06 Nov 2019 17:26:55 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=385#comment-159734 In reply to Difu Wu.

While I understand the formula you are using, you miss a few key aspects of a military retirement. Lets take the O-5. Presume the O-5 joined the service at 25…retired after 20 years. The officers age is 45 at that point. They will receive the retirement of $46K plus cost of living adjustment until their death (spouse may continue to collect a portion until their death). Your PMT/R assumes a flat rate of $46K per year. The actual retirement pay will increase each year. If you included the amount necessary to save for the cost of living, the principal of $659K would have to go up.

Second, you fail to take into account the guarantee nature of the payment. You are using a 7% return rate (historical average of stock market). However, income from private investments that would be guaranteed would have a rate of return well below 2%. If you use the .02 (reflecting risk of investment) instead of .07(stock market average return) you end up with a valuation over $2M dollars.

Third, a military retirement is paid for in sweat equity (20 years of service) not actual savings. Military members do not have their paychecks reduced to pay for the pension retirement. Military members are also eligible for a 403(b)…a 401(k) for government employees.

On the downside, a military pension has no value for the most part upon the death of the retiree and spouse….where cash can be passed on to heirs.

I am not saying a military pension for an O5 has a $2M value. I am merely pointing out that a military pension is different than most any other “investment” and using a private equity investment formula does not necessarily reflect the full value of the pension.

]]>